The Great Penny Panic: When Three Letters Caused a National Meltdown

The Day America Flipped for a Cent

On August 2, 1909, the United States Mint released the very first Lincoln Head penny. While we might think of the copper coin as the lowliest member of the currency family today, its debut caused a literal frenzy across the nation.

A "Monarchical" Scandal

Before this day, U.S. coins typically featured the abstract "Lady Liberty." Putting a real person's face on money was considered by some to be a bit "monarchical"—a practice George Washington himself had rejected to distance the new nation from British royalty. However, for Abraham Lincoln’s 100th birthday, President Teddy Roosevelt (who thought the previous coins were of "atrocious hideousness") insisted on the change.

The Riotous Release

When the coins finally hit the streets, people went wild. In New York City, police had to be called to control massive crowds outside the Sub-Treasury building. The demand was so high that banks had to limit how many pennies each person could buy. This led to a hilarious secondary market: enterprising newsboys would wait in line for their limit and immediately resell them to the public at three pennies for a nickel. That’s a 66% markup for a one-cent coin!

The Three-Letter Controversy

The real drama, however, was on the back of the coin. Designer Victor David Brenner had placed his initials, V.D.B., in small letters at the bottom of the reverse side. The public and the press were outraged, accusing Brenner of using government property for "illegal advertising" and "crass self-promotion." The backlash was so intense that the Secretary of the Treasury halted production after just four days to have the initials removed.

The Last Laugh

Because production was stopped so abruptly, the "V.D.B." pennies (especially those from the San Francisco Mint) became instant rarities. If you happen to find a 1909-S VDB penny in your couch cushions today, don't spend it—those little copper "scandals" can be worth anywhere from $1,500 to over $2,500!

---

Fun Fact: If you didn't find a rare penny today, don't worry! August 2nd is also National Ice Cream Sandwich Day. It’s the perfect way to cool down after a day of historical treasure hunting!